Call Today! (317) 213-6246

“Indianapolis’ premiere remodeling and construction professional.”

Refinish Kitchen Cabinets or Buy New Cabinetry?

cabinet refinishing

After cabinet refinishing (Photo by Eldon Lindsay)

One of the biggest decisions a homeowner must make when remodeling a kitchen is whether to completely replace existing kitchen cabinets or to salvage them by refinishing or refacing the cabinetry.

Each option comes with its own pros and cons, mainly related to cost, the type of cabinet material, and how long it will take to get the best cabinet refinishing results. Quality kitchen cabinets can last 50 years, but if yours are starting to show damage, don’t function properly or just look outdated, now may be the time to replace them with something more timeless, sturdy and durable.

Here’s what you need to know when deciding whether to refinish, reface or replace kitchen cabinets:

Refinishing Kitchen Cabinets

Kitchen cabinet refinishing requires good bones or a good foundation to build upon, since you’re keeping most of the cabinetry components and simply applying new paint or stain.

If there’s evidence of any water damage, the cabinets don’t function properly, or the cabinet box is too worn, don’t waste your time and money on refinishing. The wood won’t hold up to the sanding or chemical stripping needed to remove the existing finish.

cabinet refinishing

Before cabinet refinishing (Photo by Stephanie Larmor)

The type of wood matters, also. Cabinets made from laminate or thermofoil cannot be refinished (can’t be sanded or stripped), and cabinets made from wood with a rougher grain may prove difficult in the refinishing process.

This client’s kitchen cabinet refinishing project started with a light maple wood, featuring a smoother grain that’s ideal for refinishing. The client was happy with the function and layout of the cabinets, and she didn’t want to add any special pullout drawers or other features. We removed and sanded down each individual cabinet door, drawer and box, before filling holes from previous hardware, priming and sanding them down again. We added the finishing touch by applying two coats of medium dark gray paint for a new and modern look.

cabinet refinishing

After cabinet refinishing (Photo by Eldon Lindsay)

Refacing Kitchen Cabinets

While applying new paint or stain to existing kitchen cabinets is one way to refinish them, it’s also possible to reface cabinets by installing completely new cabinet doors and drawer fronts, or just by installing new wood or laminate veneer over the fronts.

Homeowners who go the cabinet refacing route typically like the layout and functionality of their kitchens, and they see no need to replace their cabinets. They usually want a more modern, fresher look to hide years of wear and tear.

When refacing, think about adding accessibility and functionality to well-constructed cabinets, including options like pull-out drawers, rotating shelves or open shelving. Freshen up the interior, too, by sanding or painting to match your kitchen’s new look.

cabinet refinishing

After cabinet refinishing (Photo by Eldon Lindsay)

Replacing Kitchen Cabinets

Replacing kitchen cabinets costs more than refinishing cabinets or refacing them, but the beautiful and functional result is usually worth the investment in the long run.

Do your cabinet doors stick? Are you tired of dragging out the step stool every time you need to reach something on top of the shelf? Want to enjoy cooking in your kitchen again, with everything accessible and within reach?

Hire a remodeling professional to evaluate your existing kitchen cabinets before deciding whether to refinish, reface or replace. We’ll make you feel confident in your kitchen remodeling decision.

Interested in Starting a Project?
Related Posts

4 Inspiring Garage Conversions for Families Who Need More Space

With a growing family, it’s easy to use up every bit of available living space in your home. Getting creative with solutions for cramped rooms might have you looking toward the pile of boxes inhabiting the rarely used garage. With garage conversions gaining popularity in recent years for their ability to add an impressive amount … more »

Room Addition Gives New Look to Historic Butler-Tarkington Home

Planning a room addition requires detailed planning, along with a high level of construction skill and expertise, especially when trying to update an Indianapolis Butler-Tarkington home built in 1925. For this recent room addition project, Central Construction Group worked closely with the homeowners to properly integrate a new design into the home’s existing structure while … more »

CCG Celebrates 10 Years and Counting — Thanks Indy!

By Brian Oltmanns, President/Owner of Central Construction Group Wow! I can’t believe it’s been a whole decade since I opened the doors of my Indianapolis home renovation company, Central Construction Group, Inc. If you recall, we were in the midst of a recession in 2009, so some folks may have questioned my sanity at the … more »